Skip to main content

Paul Lytton - "?" "!" (review)

 

listen on bandcamp

This music requires patience, it’s something which demands all your attention. To listen to a small excerpt and then stop it, would give a false impression of the music. For me, this is a highly overlooked masterpiece which defies the conventions of the old school, the reductionists and perhaps every thinkable area or genre. This is truly punk, so to speak.

The opening track already tells you one thing: this is a remarkable drummer. The drumming is very original, the way of playing rhythm, the temperament, the choice of sounds. He proves that he has great chops with his stick playing, and then proceeds with almost completely abandoning this virtuosic style for the bigger part of the record. It’s almost as if he can predict every listener’s expectation and says fuck you to us all. I love it! 

He then proceeds to play quite a lot in areas which I would call reductionism, but the way reductionism should have been. The carefulness and uptightness that we know so well from reductionsts of Germany, France and Switzerland is completely absent. What we hear is much more rough, harsh, almost trashy. The edges of his phrases are not cleanly cut. This is dirty reductionism. Having said that, you could almost feel that there’s a flirtation with noise music as well, but it’s much too fine and sensitive in terms of dynamics, timbre and form to be categorised as noise.

The drone-ish areas have such a captivating feeling, which I cannot explain. It’s as if there’s a kind of invisible groove behind the noise which makes it swing in an odd way. His temperament is also something quite unusual. There’s a sort of dryness to it, it doesn’t feel like he comes from a jazz tradition. Perhaps that’s why he’s so different from a drummer like Tony Oxley, even though they have so much in common. I get the feeling that he really is a mastermind, someone who understands things which most people can’t grasp, including me. The few moments when he returns to stick drumming, it’s so often cut off at the most unexpected time. One becomes unsure of the purpose of his actions, and yet it seems to make perfect sense in a kind of surrealistic way.

I believe this record could unify all kinds of listeners and practitioners of improvisation. It’s stimulating and challenging in so many different directions, and there’s no denying that this is a man who has an amazing sense of sound, dynamics, form, imagination… everything you could ask for. 

It’s shocking to me that I could only find one review of this record (on Squid’s Ear). This is a huge achievement which should have been given more space in the public forum. I suspect (but I may be wrong), that even though Lytton has a legendary status, that he’s been given somewhat of an underdog position in this scene. I think he should be given much more opportunities to show the magnitude of what he can do, which is so apparent here.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

THF Drenching - Soul On Ice (review)

  listen on bandcamp This is a hidden gem. I don’t think I’ve heard anything quite like this. I also don’t quite know what it is. It’s hard to tell by the sound of it. It may actually be a musique concrete piece and not an improvisation, but I think it has such an improvisatory feeling to it that I feel it’s worth categorising as improvisation. I suspect that THF Drenching quite enjoys leaving the listeners a bit confused about what he’s doing. His liner notes that I found on archive.org was not explanatory but just confused me further. It’s sort of reminiscent of the old musique concrete records of the 50’s and 60’s, but I think it sounds very influenced by the British style of free improv, which gives it an interesting and original feeling. The samples are hard to identify, but there could possibly be sounds of birds, videogames, typewriters… but it’s hard to tell, and that’s also the charm of it. The listeners suddenly find themselves in a world of unknown sound sources, unknown...

Sven Åke Johansson - Für Paul Klee (review)

  buy on bandcamp “Für Paul Klee” is a record combining poems by Klee read by Sven Åke Johansson with arranged improvisations by Alexander von Schlippenbach, Aki Takase, Axel Dörner, Werner Dafeldecker and Paul Lovens. The arrangement seems to be (with the exception of a few composed bits) mainly an orchestration of the improvisers. One cannot help but hear an echo in this music of pieces from the second Viennese school like “Pierrot Lunaire” by Arnold Schönberg and “Wozzeck” by Alban Berg, but this group offers something completely different consisting of the exceptional improvisational skills and the strong individualities of each musician. The form of the whole record goes through different constellations of the group, which gives it alot of space and clarity. This isn’t easy to do and not many improvising sextets (or even quartets) have been able to create such a clear and sharp result. The parametres of interplay in a sextet is something much more complex and challenging than ...

Saito / Roder / Griener - Wald (review)

  listen on bandcamp This is music which can go anywhere - but doesn’t need to. The maturity of these musicians is something which makes them role models for all improvisers. Evident on this record is a perfect balance of assertiveness, generosity and sensitivity, not to mention the immaculate instrumental skills and imagination of these musicians. The sound of the trio (of vibraphone, bass and drums) definitely has a jazz connotation and a deep jazz influence. It is however a kind of very fresh, open jazz, that’s behaving more like the interactions of European free improvisers. It’s the best of both worlds, I would say. The ability to swing, to be dynamic, to pause, to bring about different kinds of directions - it’s all there. The second track shows something which is very untypical of jazz, and it’s a very exciting contrast to the more busy and swinging parts. This has a meditative quality, with long sounds, bowed vibraphone, more atmospheric. It makes your ears wake up. You rea...